#14 Book Club Meeting – The tattooist of Auschwitz

Hello everyone, 

Congratulations to our regular Book Club members who attended the Science & Engineering Challenge during the last week of Term 2. It was great to hear about how well the day went for participating Cerdon students. I’m sure that you all found the Challenge to be a positive learning experience.

Special thanks to Mrs Ryan who hosted the 14th Book Club meeting and Ms McNamara for sharing news about attending a recent book talk with Heather Morris, author of ‘The tattooist of Auschwitz’, at Sutherland Public Library.   

Here is an edited transcript from Ms McNamara’s chat at Book Club on the 1st July about listening to Heather Morris:

Attending author talks give you the opportunity to hear about how a story came to be developed. ‘The tattooist of Auschwitz’ is about Lali who lived in Melbourne (he died a few years ago), he and his wife (Gita) were survivors of the Holocaust. They survived one of the concentration camps in Auschwitz and Lali’s job at the camp was to be the tattooist (he was the person who would mark prisoners with a number). Heather Morris, the author of ‘The tattooist of Auschwitz’, lives in Melbourne. Lali wanted to tell his story of surviving the Holocaust to someone who wasn’t Jewish. He wanted to have a non-Jewish person tell his story as he felt that, while a Jewish person would have a deep understanding of the Holocaust, each Jewish person would have their own unique personal story (e.g lost a family member, or possibly many family members). So he didn’t want his story to be affected by another Jewish person’s story, he wanted his story to be free of that, which is why Heather, who is not Jewish, got to write this story. Heather spoke about how she met him and developed trust with him so that he could actually tell her his story. And the way that came about was through his dogs. Lali had a couple of big dogs and he was a bit wary about whether he could trust Heather and relate to her. When playing with his dogs he would throw a ball and they would return it to him.  During the second meeting with Heather, he threw the ball and the dogs went and got the ball but they took it back to Heather. After this Lali said to Heather “you are accepted, my dogs think you are okay, so now I can tell you my story of surviving the Holocaust.” Heather is a social worker and she had worked in a hospital emergency department in Melbourne for twenty years. This experience was important as Heather was used to helping people who have been traumatised tell their stories, she had a lot of skills (such as listening skills, and hearing people describe what has happened to them).

One of the questions raised was “… was Lali a collaborator with the Nazis?” (as he was the one tattooing the numbers onto the prisoners)? In doing this role, he was able to survive and at the same time, he was able to help save some people.

He met his wife in the camp and they fell in love in the camp. After surviving the camp, she would never talk about it. She would say that “it is past and it is finished, I’m not going there.” It was not until she had passed away, that Lali was able to talk about his experience in the camp.

In the book, Heather mentions a young girl called Cilka. Cilka was a young girl that the Nazis kind of groomed to work for them. She didn’t have a choice, none of these people had a choice, it was either work for us or die basically. But when the Russians came and liberated the camps after WWII, they actually took her and sent her to prison for ten years because they said “you have been a collaborator with the Nazis.” Heather, since writing this book, has had contact from many other people who are survivors of the Holocaust and, when she did our talk at Sutherland, she had just come back from Tel Aviv in Israel, where she had been interviewing another woman who was 93, telling her story. Heather has written the story about Cilka and it’s coming out in October. ‘Cilka’s Journey’ is the sequel to ‘The tattooist of Auschwitz’.

Ms McNamara shared a photo taken with Heather Morris who has signed a copy of the YA version of the book for Book Club. 

Ms McNamara with Heather Morris, author of ‘The tattooist of Auschwitz’, Sutherland Public Library, Monday 17 June 2019

You can access details about ‘The tattooist of Auschwitz’ by Heather Morris here.

You might also like to read this article published in The New York Times on November, 8, 2018: ‘The Tattooist of Auschwitz’ and the History in Historical Fiction.

This recent podcast on Radio National’s: Sum Of All Parts is interesting to listen to. You can access it here: 12.0 The Tattoowierer

For students interested in reading books about the holocaust, you might like to access this Padlet Reading List: WWII and the Holocaust (you can click on the pink link below the title of each book to take you to the book’s details in eLibrary). 

Other books discussed included:

  • The Greatcoats series by Sebastian de Castell (recommended by Ashley)
  • King of Scars by Leigh Bardugo (recommended by Emma)
  • The Winter Rose by Jennifer Donnelly (Book 2 in the Tea Rose trilogy) (recommended by Anjana)
  • Beautiful Demons (eBook series) (recommended by Jade)

As discussed, for our next book meeting, we will be reading books by Australian authors including:

Lenny’s Book of Everything by Karen Foxlee

Catching Teller Crow by Ambelin and Ezekial Kwaymullina

Promise me happy by Robert Newton 

Jasper Jones by Craig Silvey

Finally, you might like to vote in this year’s INKY Awards. Voting closes on the 18th August and you can enter the draw to win a fantastic prize. One of our past Book Club books is on the shortlist!

Looking forward to our next meeting,

Mrs Sylaprany, Mrs Ryan & Mrs Hanratty

Ghosts by Raina Telgemeier

Reviewed by: Sarah, Year 7, 8.7.2019

Title:  Ghosts

Author:  Raina Telgemeier

Format: Graphic Novel

Intended audience: Teenage girls

Setting: Bahia de la Luna, California

Main characters: Catrina, Maya, Carlos, Mum and Dad. 

Review: Ghosts by Raina Telgemeier is a great holiday read. This book made me feel inspired and always kept me wanting more. One of the main characters, Maya has cystic fibrosis. This book helps to raise awareness for cystic fibrosis as well as teach you about all the medication, treatments and symptoms. This book has been written extremely well, the way Raina has written it makes you feel all the feelings that the characters feel as well as the suspense of the story. Some parts of the story can feel like they are going on forever and feel like they are drifting off from the main story line but they are still intriguing. As always the end of the book is the best part of the book; this means that I could not stop reading at the end of the book.

Opinion : My overall opinion is that this is a really great book to read as it will teach you new things as well as give you a thrilling experience.

Select a few words to describe the story:  thrilling, educational, keep you wanting more, suspenseful.

Recommendation and rating (out of 5): I would recommend this book to girls aged 10 – 14 and would give it 4 out of 5 stars.

Wings by Aprilynne Pyke

Reviewed by: Christina, Year 8, 8.7.2019.

Title:  Wings

Author:  Aprilynne Pike

Genre:  Fantasy

Intended audience:  Years 7-9

Setting:  Crescent City, California

Main characters:  Laurel, David, Tamani.

Review: Fifteen-year-old Laurel Sewell has lived her whole life on her family’s land near Orick, California and the Redwood National and State Parks, where she was homeschooled by her hippie parents, Sarah Sewell and Mark Sewell. So when she moves to Crescent City, California to attend public school at Del Norte High School, Laurel has some large adjustments to make. They move because of her father buying a bookstore, which has always been a dream for both of her parents. While she misses being outdoors all the time, she’s getting along pretty well at her new school and soon befriends David Lawson, a handsome and sweet boy who understands Laurel and her strict vegan diet. Things are looking up for her until a bump between Laurel’s shoulders sprouts into a small bud on her back. This soon turns into a big plant that is growing from inside her, leaving Laurel confused out of her mind and very uncomfortable covering it up not to mention painful, it is apart of her.

Laurel is very hesitant to tell her recent sprouting problem to her parents. She seeks help from David, and together they investigate the strange phenomenon of her “wings” or blossom. Their only clue is that when she was about three years old, she was found on her parents’ doorstep in a basket, with no knowledge of where she came from. It turns out that Laurel is actually a more advanced evolution of a plant; more or less a faerie. The two soon discover that Laurel’s whole body is of plant cells and that she is a plant stating the reason she is vegan.

On a trip back to the family home, Laurel’s world is forever changed when she encounters Tamani, someone that seems awfully familiar to her yet a complete stranger. Laurel finds herself drawn to him, and he provides many of the answers she has been seeking. It turns out she’s not even human; like Tamani, she’s a faerie. Apparently she is a faerie that was sent to the humans, to her parents to inherit their land, which holds something very important to the fae. This plan breaks down when Laurel’s family moves and puts the land up for sale. The gate to Avalon, which the faeries have protected for ages, is now threatened, and Laurel must help save the faeries’ secret, protect her family, sort out her confused feelings for David and Tamani, and figure out her own identity—and her place in both worlds.

Overall opinion: This story jarred my heart every few pages. It may be a little cheesy, but it is so cute. Tam is just adorable in how he has loved her since he was little, but David is so nice and understanding. I never knew how Laurel ended up choosing between the two, as one of them will be heartbroken and the other happy with her, but by the end of the series she finally chooses and I see why. But I’m not going to spoil anything, although I want to so badly. I don’t even know how Laurel made it through all those secrets for her whole life. Thinking about everyday like it was a lie, not knowing who her real parents were, not being able to remember her past as a fae when she was little, and not even being able to see the real world for how it really is. This story was heartbreaking and emotional … but it was the most beautiful story I have ever heard, especially with the happy ending … after the series finished :).

Select a few words to describe the story: – Emotional – Heartbreaking – Cute – Intriguing – Surprising.

Recommendation and rating (out of 5): I would recommend this book, including the series, to readers who love a bit of adventure and venturing off to magical places with mythical beings. Also to the readers who enjoy reading about love and how it accommodates the journey the characters go on. Lastly to the readers who love a happy ending and I’m not talking about, “And they all lived happily ever after”, I’m talking about the feeling of a happy ending. When finishing a book you come across the last few words and something clicks. You can just tell that it is the end. Not because you’re on the last page of the book, but because of the value the words hold. Yeah, sure that sounds cheesy, but it’s kinda true. When you’re so into the book, which you will be for this one, you feel like you’re in the book itself like the authors want you to be. You become one with the book, that it’s like you’re writing the ending, so, you know what the last words mean. That’s how I feel about this book, so I’m going to give it a five out of five.

Hitler’s Daughter by Jackie French

Reviewed by Joanna, Year 8, 4.7.2019.

Title:  Hitler’s Daughter

Author:  Jackie French

Genre:  Holocaust

Intended audience:  Children maybe 10+

Setting:  Australia – on rainy days

Main characters:  Anna, Mark, Little Heidi, Hitler, Fräulein Gelber.

Hi Bella!

I heard you had trouble finding a book for the holidays, so I decided to share this book review of a novel that I just finished reading! I know you like holocaust themed stories so this one’s for you. It’s called ‘Hitler’s Daughter’ by Jackie French.  It’s about a group of friends telling stories to each other. Although, one of the main characters, Anna, had the best story and all the other children got hooked into it! Anna continued telling this story about a little girl called Heidi, whose father, Hitler, does not treat her very well as they are going through the holocaust. In my opinion the last part is the best and I know that you’ll be shocked once you find out the plot twist. This book, for me, was a great holiday read and I really did enjoy it. There weren’t many funny bits, however there were a little about Little Tracey, another character of this book, as the stories Anna tells about her are cute and funny. This book really made me feel so upset for Heidi, as what she went through with her father was not how she deserved to be treated. This book is really engaging and I hope you use this recommendation. Anyway, happy reading and I hope this is the book you are looking for to read this holidays!

Joanna

Opinion: Overall I really like this book, and I’ve read it more than once. It’s great for people who are interested in the holocaust and for younger children as well, as this book is about young children.

Select a few words to describe the story: Sad, interesting, captivating.

Recommendation (i.e who do you recommend this book to) and rating (out of 5):  I really did enjoy this book, as I’m very interested in holocaust themed books, as well as true stories, which is why I’m so interested in this history. I rate this book 5 stars, not only because I love it, but because I feel like many others, my age, younger or older, would too.